The Demutualization of the Colombo Stock Exchange Act aims to convert the CSE from a company limited by guarantee into a company limited by shares. This transformation is designed to enhance governance, transparency, and operational efficiency. The following report provides an analysis of the Bill 405/2018 presented by the Prime Minister and Minister of National Policies and Economic Affairs on 19th of February, 2018 and highlights key areas relevant to legislative review. New Parliament of Sri Lanka likely to consider this enactment in 2025 in the backdrop of the booming stock market and CSE’s expected contribution to the economy and financial sector of Sri Lanka.

Key Objectives of the Bill

1. Demutualization Structure: The Bill seeks to transform the CSE into a company limited by shares to promote better governance and reduce the influence of member-brokers on operational decision-making.
2. Share Allocation: A dual allocation system is proposed:
   • 60% of shares are reserved for members of the exchange.
   • 40% of shares are allocated to the Capital Market Development Fund (CMDF) to promote market development.
3. Governance Enhancements:
   • A mixed board structure with independent directors and broker representatives.
   • A nomination panel to recommend board members.
4. Market Development: The establishment of the CMDF aims to further public interest by fostering market infrastructure, investor education, and access to capital markets.
5. Listing Requirement: The demutualized CSE is required to list itself within three years of conversion, ensuring accountability and transparency.

Strengths of the Bill

1. Improved Governance: Introducing independent directors reduces the risk of undue influence by member-brokers. Mandating a nomination panel ensures transparency in the appointment of board members.
2. Transparency and Market Discipline: Listing the demutualized CSE enhances public scrutiny and compliance with corporate governance norms. Restrictions on dividends and share issuance before listing ensure financial prudence.
3. Continuity of Operations: Provisions ensure the seamless transfer of assets, liabilities, and staff to the new entity, minimizing disruption.
4. Promotion of Public Interest: The CMDF’s mandate to promote investor education and infrastructure development aligns with broader market development goals.

Challenges and Areas for Improvement

1. Board Independence: While the Bill mandates independent directors, it does not provide detailed criteria for independence or professional qualifications. Strengthening these provisions could enhance governance.
2. Cap on Ownership: The 5% ownership limit per member is commendable but requires robust enforcement mechanisms to prevent indirect control through affiliated entities.
3. Listing Timeline: The three-year timeline for listing is ambitious. Introducing periodic reporting requirements could ensure progress and transparency.
4. Oversight of the CMDF: The CMDF’s utilization of funds should be subject to detailed reporting and regular audits to ensure accountability.
5. Technological Innovation: The Bill lacks provisions to promote technological advancements, which are critical for maintaining global competitiveness.
6. Investor Protections: Post-listing, mechanisms to protect minority shareholders and resolve disputes need further elaboration.

Recommendations

1. Enhance Governance Standards:
   • Specify professional and independence criteria for board members.
   • Introduce mandatory training for directors to improve oversight capabilities.
2. Strengthen Ownership Regulations: Include provisions to monitor and prevent indirect ownership exceeding the 5% cap.
3. Accountability for Listing Milestones: Mandate interim progress reports and milestone reviews to track the entity’s readiness for listing.
4. Auditing the CMDF: Require annual audits and public disclosure of the CMDF’s activities and financials.
5. Promote Technological Advancements: Introduce incentives for the demutualized CSE to invest in modern trading platforms and cybersecurity measures.
6. Bolster Minority Shareholder Rights: Include dispute resolution mechanisms and safeguards to ensure fair treatment of minority shareholders.

Conclusion

The Demutualization of the Colombo Stock Exchange is a progressive step towards enhancing the efficiency and transparency of Sri Lanka’s capital market. By addressing the identified gaps and incorporating the recommended improvements, the Act can create a robust framework for sustainable market development, aligning the CSE with global best practices. Legislators are encouraged to prioritize these refinements to ensure successful implementation and long-term benefits.

Download Bill